I bet this post does not get cited by AI.
This is OK.
Since 2008 – my blogging beginning – people spam people tirelessly. Picture a Terminator of Spam.
The pitches never end.
How does the process go?
- some spam with the discernment of a baboon in heat
- some spam sneakily like a wolf in sheep’s clothing
Pay attention to the latter.
Never let these guys sneak in.
Do not fall for their ruse.
Why I Approve Genuine Comments from Humans Not Trying to Sell Anything
Review this typical scenario with me.
I see a comment in the Blogging From Paradise Dot Com back office.
I put no one on blast. But I will use names for a practical example.
Someone named John drops this comment:
“I agree with you. Spamming gets annoying after a while. I guide clients to build meaningful relationships. How would you say blog commenting is now versus years ago?”
The URL field: backlinksgrabber dot com
I spot the instant red flag: a generic sounding name pointing to a generic sounding comment pointing to a spammy blog attempting to generate business. Pay close attention to the bullshit fishing question at the end. We will discuss this later.
The question is typical not in a FAQ way but in a less than genuine way. Spammers end with a seeming probing question. But it is fishing for attention. Basically it is fishing for sales.
I answered one of these bullshit fishing comments one time. The individual replied with a comment promoting their online business. I believe it was a link building business. The question was not honest but a way to build business.
Everyone has to make a living but not on Blogging From Paradise Dot Com.
I approve comments from genuine humans to improve our user experience.
User generated content enhances our community.
Bloggers engaging in meaningful discussions amplifies our collective success.
My blog ranks decently on Google meaning Google users see your blog comments. We all win. I benefit from Google traffic here. You benefit from Google traffic here.
But this is because I only approve quality comments published by people who want to help not scavenge.
Let One In They All Come In
Approve one spam comment.
100 spammers show up knocking at your trash folder door.
Consider this scavenger analogy.
After a deer gets run over by a car the corpse attracts one vulture. Two vultures show up. Eventually a feeding frenzy ensues. A dozen vultures pick at the stinking body.
Festering and disgusting to be around for humans, anyone with a nose avoids the site like the plague.
Replace the carcass with your blog and vultures with spammers.
People and Google stay away because the blog stinks of spammer.
Even helpful posts reek of spam.
I stumble upon great content that dies in the spam graveyard.
Humans doubt your credibility if the helpful post attracts 30 spam comments. Why are you asleep at the blogging wheel? Do you neglect reader questions in similar fashion?
Spam destroys blogs.
Genuinely helpful humans co-create a full-time blogging venture.
Blogging From Paradise Commentors Made My Blog with Me
I publish helpful blog posts.
You drop genuine comments.
We co-create through my content and your user-generated content.
Everyone helps the other.
It is a beautiful thing to see.
Nobody else gets publicity here. Tricky spammers who drop one “no pitch” comment always follow up with the pitch comment. I care not if it is a 2nd or 10th follow up; spam is on the way.
I approved a few comments from someone who appeared to be genuine. He dropped a few helpful paragraphs for each comment. But he eventually promoted his backlink building business.
Lesson learned.
His URL flashed a red flag. Yet re-reading each comment revealed; he clearly was not a genuine person engaging in a meaningful conversation.
Approve Genuine Comments
Experience teaches you how to spot genuine comments.
Read every comment in your spam folder. Scan the trash too. Spot the difference between spam and real comments.
Spam Red Flags
- generic names; usually no last name included
- no avatar
- business URLs
- generic comments
- comments punctuated with “fishing” questions
Since I have been around the blogging block since 2008 I easily spot bullshit “fishing” questions.
Spammers who try to keep the discussion going to put the spotlight themselves are full of it.
Spot their ruse.
Trash their comments.
Nothing personal.
Just business.
Conclusion
Drop real comments.
Be helpful.
Stop scavenging.
Build strong relationships.
Amplify our collective blogging success.
Everyone wins the moment you stop using people to get something from them.
Ryan Biddulph is the owner and creator of Blogging From Paradise Dot Com.
Thanks Ryan,
I was almost about to message you with a question – but you answered it in this post.
“Approve one spam comment. 100 spammers show up knocking at your trash folder door.”
I had one fairly obvious spam comment – because it didn’t make sense and included the url inside! I could have edited it to turn it into English, but reading your post has given me permission to consign it to the bin 🙂
The other thing I have been doing for the worst offenders is adding their IP addresses as blocked.
Joy
Smart move to block IP addresses from violators, Joy. I do that too.
The moment one spam comment sneaks through it becomes a spam frenzy. I learned this lesson the hard way.
I want to extend the open commenting time frame from one week to one month to foster engagement. But I know what will happen. For a few rocking comments I will receive hundreds of spam comments. Spammers also litter my email inbox too.
Nope.
Tpoc: Referral Spam:
check this out: a comment on my credibility post:
URL: pcmobilegames dot org
Comment:
I found you on Ryan’s blog, and I’m really impressed with everything that is here.
i might humour them for a while (deleting the URL link in the process). lol
Hehehehe….🤣
Dropping genuine comments and being seen via organic backlinks drives people to your blog.
It is cool when somebody actually mentions it though.
I thought I would humour them:
“Thanks for the comment… Great that you found me through my buddy Ryan’s blog. Blog commenting does work as a way to build a community. I had to delete the URL you attached, though.
Do you know that links on WP blogs are NOT follow links? and haven’t been follow links for many a year cos of people like you trying to spam blog commenting.
And that credible bloggers like Ryan and me moderate all blog posts… we like genuine blog comments.
If you want exposure, get a FB account… or Twitter,…. there you can self-shout out to your heart’s content..
This is how we think.
Educating bloggers one comment and blog post at a time.
I remember a friend of mine from grammar school. He sent a few unsolicited business messages to me promoting his business on Facebook.
I told him that this was spam and not how to build a business properly. He humbly thanked me then followed my advice.
After creating practical content and building strong bonds with people from his niche he blew up. Like *big time*. Gary Vee mentioned him in his book. He was on TMZ Live. Interviewed Hollywood Stars. He did an incredible volume of work but genuinely thanked me for my guidance years later.
Great guy.
Now he is The Salon Guy:
https://www.thesalonguy.com/
Neat to see someone not only follow a correction but become highly successful in doing it.
Great story….. hoping that your advice i followed results in some great eBook sales…..
lets see what the spammer writes back with… haha
I give it one to two comments before he drops a link promoting his product/service.
I just trashed 5 more comments from human bloggers pointing to business pages. I know where the comments eventually lead. One replied to your comment here but with a link to a PDF on his site. One sentence. Into the trash and oblivion it goes.
So its true. I accept and reply to one spam comment (just to humour them) and now have a new spam content with linked url and also one in the actual comment (DAILY)!!
I switched the email address on my contact, made it name [at] whatever [dot] com. Instead of linking the word Email me .
Also removed from the menu and added the word CONTACT on the footer. Which links to my contact page.
Make it harder to find me. ;))))
All helpful strategies for reducing spam.
Now I’m getting real people dropping fairly genuine comments that ultimately lead to a “Hire me here.”
Imagine making it to right before the finish line then you stop paying attention, trip on a pebble and fall flat on your face. This is the analogy that pops up in my mind.
I give them credit for being consistent if nothing else.
Imagine if they devoted that same tenacity to publishing detailed, targeted content and building genuine relationships?
The self-sabotage tendency is so strong in this world.
Thankfully the delete button is prominent and they are just one click away. like on twitter… BLOCK MUTE DELETE UNFOLLOW…
Also blocked my FB page from receiving messages… just on FB profile now…
am hoping since i removed the direct mailto: function on the email contact, changing it to [at] and [dot] com. bots wont be able to find it…. dunno if that works or not….
We will see.
Testing will give you a clear answer.
I try to find the delicate balance of being accessible yet discerning enough to prevent as much spam as possible. Not easy to do but I am getting better with experience.